Quick answer: Commercial property insurance valuation is the replacement cost figure your building and contents limits are based on, and in Ontario it is easy to fall behind. Statistics Canada reported on October 29, 2026 that non-residential construction prices rose 4.3% over the past year, with structural steel leading the increase. If your limit still reflects an old appraisal, a co-insurance clause can cut what you are paid on even a small claim. The fix is an up-to-date replacement cost appraisal, adjusted each renewal with Statistics Canada’s Building Construction Price Index.
Most business owners set their property limit once and renew it without thinking about it again. That worked when construction costs barely moved. It doesn’t any more. This guide explains why your building’s insured value may be out of date this renewal season, how the co-insurance clause turns that gap into a smaller claim cheque, and how to keep your commercial property insurance valuation current between full appraisals.
Why your commercial property insurance valuation may be out of date this renewal
Statistics Canada’s latest Building construction price indexes release, for the third quarter of 2026, shows that it keeps getting more expensive to put up a commercial building:
- Non-residential building construction prices rose 1.2% in the third quarter of 2026, following a 1.4% increase in the second quarter.
- Year over year, non-residential prices were up 4.3% across the 15 metropolitan areas Statistics Canada tracks.
- Among the building trades, structural steel framing rose 3.3% in the quarter, the largest increase, followed by conveying equipment such as elevators (3.1%) and metal fabrications (2.1%).
- Builders pointed to higher material, fuel, transportation and labour costs.
Tariffs are part of the picture. The Department of Finance announced on August 25, 2026 that Canada would impose counter-tariffs of 15%, 25% and 50% on $27.6 billion of U.S. imports, effective September 8, 2026. Steel and aluminum products that were previously subject to a 25% counter-tariff moved to 50%. Statistics Canada’s release links the jump in metal and steel prices to tariff pressures and supply chain disruptions.
This isn’t a one-quarter blip either. In February 2025, the Insurance Bureau of Canada (IBC) noted that construction costs rose 66% between 2019 and October 2024, while general inflation over the same period was 19%. A building limit that tracked general inflation, or that hasn’t changed at all, could now be well short of what a rebuild costs.
How the co-insurance clause turns an old value into a smaller cheque
According to IBC, most commercial property policies include a co-insurance clause. It requires you to insure the property to a set percentage of its replacement cost, generally 80% to 90% (some policies use 100%). If your limit falls below that level, the insurer pays only a proportional share of the loss, and you become a “co-insurer” for the rest. We explain the mechanics in more detail in our earlier post on co-insurance, the least known exposure. This article is about keeping the number behind it accurate.
Here is how a gap plays out on a partial loss. The building’s limit was set at $2,000,000 based on an older appraisal, but rebuilding it today would cost $2,600,000. The policy has a 90% co-insurance clause.
| Item | Amount |
|---|---|
| Current replacement cost | $2,600,000 |
| Insurance required (90%) | $2,340,000 |
| Insurance carried | $2,000,000 |
| Covered loss (e.g. a roof fire) | $400,000 |
| Insurer pays ($2,000,000 ÷ $2,340,000 × $400,000) | about $341,880 |
| Owner’s co-insurance shortfall | about $58,120, plus the deductible |
The loss is a fraction of the $2,000,000 limit, yet the claim is still reduced. That’s what catches owners off guard: co-insurance applies to partial losses, not only to total ones. (This is a simplified illustration. How the deductible is applied and the exact clause wording vary by policy.)
IBC also notes that the co-insurance clause can apply to property beyond the building, including business interruption coverage. That means your revenue figures need the same attention as your bricks and mortar.
How to update your commercial property insurance valuation between appraisals
IBC recommends getting a professional replacement cost appraisal of your building. The appraisal should account for materials, labour, debris removal, building bylaws and other variables that affect what it would actually cost to rebuild. According to IBC, you can use that base appraisal for up to three years, adjusting it each year with Statistics Canada’s Building Construction Price Index to estimate the current rebuild cost at renewal.

In practice, that looks like this:
- Start with a professional replacement cost appraisal. Market value, purchase price and municipal property assessment are not replacement cost. Land is not rebuilt, and resale value has little to do with what contractors charge.
- Note the appraisal date and building type. Statistics Canada publishes separate indexes for six non-residential building types (an office building, a warehouse, a shopping centre, a factory, a school and a bus depot) across 15 metropolitan areas. In Ontario, those are Toronto, Ottawa-Gatineau (Ontario part) and London.
- Apply the change in the index since the appraisal date. As a rough illustration, a building appraised at $2,000,000 a year ago would be about $2,086,000 if you applied the 4.3% composite non-residential increase. Your broker can use the index for the closest building type and metro area instead of the 15-city composite.
- Add anything new. Additions, renovations, new mechanical systems, racking and leasehold improvements all change the replacement cost.
- Re-appraise when the base gets stale. After about three years, or after major renovations, IBC’s guidance points to a fresh professional appraisal rather than another index adjustment.
Our commercial property insurance page outlines the coverage we place for Ontario building owners and tenants.
What the construction price index doesn’t capture
The index is a useful adjustment tool, but it isn’t a full valuation. Statistics Canada’s index measures contractor prices for materials, labour, equipment, overhead and profit. It excludes value-added taxes, land, design and real estate fees. Rebuilding after a serious loss can also involve:
- Demolition and debris removal, which IBC lists as part of a proper replacement cost appraisal.
- Bylaw upgrades. An older building may have to be rebuilt to current codes, not to its original design.
- Architect, engineering and permit costs, which the index does not measure.
- Regional pressure after a catastrophe. When many buildings in one area are damaged at once, contractors and materials get scarce and prices rise.
Ask your broker how each of these is handled in your policy, whether through the building limit, separate sublimits or extensions, so you know what the index adjustment will and won’t fix.
Contents, equipment and business interruption need their own numbers
Underinsurance isn’t only a building problem. IBC advises owners to track the value of stock and equipment so their limits can replace them after a major loss. The September 2026 counter-tariffs apply to a long list of U.S. goods, and the Department of Finance publishes the full product list. If your equipment, parts or stock come from the U.S., replacing them may now cost more than it did when you set your contents limit. If you rely on specialised machinery, equipment breakdown insurance deserves a look alongside your property limits.
Business interruption is the other gap. In a July 2025 review of Canadian catastrophe losses, IBC found that many affected businesses carried only 12 months of business interruption coverage, while rebuilding can take 18, 24 or even 36 months depending on location, labour, permitting and supply chains. Higher construction costs and longer timelines go together, so revisit your indemnity period and revenue figures at the same time as your building value. Our business interruption insurance page covers the options.
A pre-renewal commercial property insurance valuation checklist
- Find the date and amount of your last professional replacement cost appraisal.
- Confirm your co-insurance percentage (80%, 90% or 100%) and whether it applies to building, contents and business interruption.
- Ask your broker to apply the latest Building Construction Price Index for your building type and nearest metro area.
- List any renovations, additions or new equipment since the last review.
- Update stock and equipment values using current replacement prices, including tariff-affected items.
- Check your business interruption indemnity period against a realistic rebuild timeline.
- If you lease, check what your lease makes you responsible for insuring, including improvements you’ve paid for.
- Book a full re-appraisal if your base appraisal is more than about three years old.
How AAXEL can help
AAXEL Insurance Brokers works with Ontario businesses to review property limits, co-insurance terms and business interruption coverage before renewal. If you’d like a second look at your commercial property insurance valuation, or you’re shopping your renewal, request a business insurance quote. For a broader overview of the coverage a business typically carries, see our guide to business insurance coverage and costs.
Frequently asked questions
What is commercial property insurance valuation?
It’s the process of working out how much it would cost to rebuild your building and replace your business property today, which then sets your policy limits. It is based on replacement cost, not market value or purchase price.
How often should I update my commercial property insurance valuation?
IBC suggests a professional replacement cost appraisal that can be used for up to three years, adjusted each year with Statistics Canada’s Building Construction Price Index. Re-appraise sooner after major renovations or additions.
Is replacement cost the same as market value?
No. Market value includes land and reflects what a buyer would pay. Replacement cost is what it would cost to rebuild the structure with similar materials at today’s prices. Insuring to market value can leave you over- or underinsured.
What is a co-insurance penalty?
If your limit is below the percentage of replacement cost your policy requires (often 80% to 90%), the insurer pays only a proportional share of a covered loss. You pay the difference, even on a partial claim.
Does the co-insurance clause apply to business interruption insurance?
It can. IBC notes that the clause also applies to property other than the building and is used in business interruption coverage, so revenue figures should be kept current too.
How much have construction costs gone up in Canada?
Statistics Canada reported that non-residential building construction prices rose 4.3% in the year to the third quarter of 2026, and 1.2% in that quarter alone. IBC reported a 66% increase in construction costs from 2019 to October 2024.
Do tariffs affect my business insurance?
They can affect what it costs to rebuild or replace property. Canada’s September 8, 2026 counter-tariffs raised the rate on many U.S. steel and aluminum products to 50%, and Statistics Canada links recent metal and steel price increases to tariff pressures. Higher replacement costs mean your limits may need to rise.
Can I use the construction price index instead of an appraisal?
Not on its own. The index adjusts a reliable base appraisal. It doesn’t capture your building’s specific features, bylaw requirements, debris removal or professional fees, and it excludes taxes and land.
Sources
- Statistics Canada, The Daily: Building construction price indexes, third quarter 2026 (October 29, 2026). Quarterly and annual price changes, trade-level increases, cost drivers and index coverage.
- Statistics Canada, Table 18-10-0289-01: Building construction price indexes, by type of building and division. Index data by building type and metropolitan area.
- Statistics Canada, Building Construction Price Index survey description. Building types and metropolitan areas covered.
- Department of Finance Canada, Canada announces targeted countermeasures… in response to U.S. tariffs (August 25, 2026). Counter-tariff rates, value and effective date.
- Department of Finance Canada, Complete list of U.S. products subject to counter-tariffs.
- Insurance Bureau of Canada, Are You Properly Insured? What Small Businesses Can Learn from a Tragic Loss (February 4, 2025). Co-insurance, replacement cost appraisals, the three-year index adjustment, and the 66% construction cost increase.
- Insurance Bureau of Canada, Rise in catastrophic weather events exposes issues with underinsurance for many businesses (July 9, 2025). Business interruption periods and underinsurance.
- Insurance Bureau of Canada, How business insurance rates are set and Types of business coverage.
This article provides general information about commercial property insurance in Ontario as of November 4, 2026. It is not legal, appraisal or financial advice. Policy wording, co-insurance terms and coverage vary by insurer. Speak with a licensed broker about your own policy.




