Call for a quote: 1-866-358-2860

Ontario appeal court rules on discussions between defence lawyers and expert witnesses

-

The Court of Appeal for Ontario suggested this week that lawyers representing clients in lawsuits can discuss and review draft reports with expert witnesses and do not need to disclose all written communications.

In a major ruling, the Ontario Court of Appeal has overturned a murder conviction and ordered a new trial, finding that the trial judge erred in not allowing the defence to discuss its expert reports with the expert witnesses. The case involved the 2015 shooting death of Johnathan Z Hunting, which the defence said was accidental.

The jury at the first trial convicted the accused, Denny Ross, of second-degree murder. On appeal, Ross’ lawyer, Paul Burstein, argued that the trial judge had erred in not allowing him to discuss the expert reports with the witnesses before they testified. The Appeal Court agreed, saying the defence should have been allowed to “challenge and test” the witnesses’ opinions.

The ruling is a victory for defence lawyers, who have long argued that they should be able to discuss their experts’ reports with the witnesses before they testify. The Ontario Crown Attorneys’ Association had argued that such discussions would lead to “mini-trials” outside the courtroom.

“While some judges have expressed concern that the impartiality of expert evidence may be tainted by discussions with counsel …. banning undocumented discussions between counsel and expert witnesses or mandating disclosure of all written communications is unsupported by and contrary to existing authority, ” wrote Mr. Justice Robert Sharpe of the Court of Appeal for Ontario in a decision released Thursday.

The Ontario appeal court has ruled that discussions between defence lawyers and expert witnesses are protected by solicitor-client privilege. This means that these discussions cannot be used as evidence in court. This ruling is important because it protects the rights of defence lawyers to confidential communication with their clients.

Read More: Protecting Business Property: Property Insurance

Disclaimer: All information in this site is provided "as is", with no guarantee of completeness, accuracy, timeliness or of the results obtained from the use of this information. Information is for awareness purpose only and you should speak to a licensed insurance broker for specific and relevanbt answers.

Share this article

spot_img

Recent posts

spot_img

Popular categories

Frequently Asked Questions

How Does Choosing Between Market Value and Replacement Cost Affect My Premiums?

Choosing between market value and replacement cost significantly affects...

What Are the Financial Risks of Not Having Gap Insurance on a Leased Car?

Not having gap insurance on a leased car exposes...

Does Condo Insurance Cover Damages From Natural Disasters?

Condo insurance, also known as HO-6 insurance, may cover...

What Are the Consequences of Not Having Commercial Auto Insurance?

Not having commercial auto insurance can lead to serious...

What Kind of Incidents Does Product Liability Insurance Cover?

Product liability insurance covers incidents where a product causes...

What Are the Benefits of Adding Riders to My Life Insurance Policy?

Adding riders to your life insurance policy provides extra...

Why Might Replacement Cost Be Higher Than Market Value for Insurance?

Replacement cost can be higher than market value for...

Can Lessees Choose Not to Have Gap Insurance?

Yes, lessees can choose not to have gap insurance,...

What Are the Common Exclusions in a Condo Insurance Policy?

Common exclusions in a condo insurance policy typically include...